|
Cooper's and Sharp-shinned hawks pose a real ID challenge, even
for longtime birders. Throughout the year, there is great variation in
plumage and in size for these two species. They look so much alike that
no single field mark stands out to help bird watchers easily tell one
from the other.
Size is the defining factor, but that's sometimes
hard to judge with a single bird. The rule of thumb is that a Cooper's
Hawk is about the size of an American Crow and the Sharp-shinned Hawk
is more the size of a jay. You can compare the relative sizes of those
species in the graphic below to get an idea of the difference between
the two hawks.
 |
| L-R: Blue Jay, Steller's Jay, American Crow. Graphic by
Kevin McGowan |
Below are a few ID guidelines that may help--at least some of
the time! Clicking on the bird name will also take you to more
information in our Online Bird
Guide.
|
Cooper's
Hawk - Adult
(Accipiter cooperii)
|
|
Sharp-shinned Hawk - Adult
(Accipiter striatus)
|
|

|
|

|
|
Photo by Gary Botello
Keys to ID:
-
Crow-sized, on average
14-20 inches long; female larger than the male
-
Thick body and broad
chest-- lower center of gravity than Sharp-shinned
-
Thicker legs than
Sharp-shinned
-
Long, rounded tail
with a broad white band. The middle tail feathers are usually the
longest.
-
Dark cap; feathers on
back of head often raised, giving it a crested look never seen on the
Sharp-shinned.
-
Slow wing beats that could
easily be counted; the head projects far beyond the
wings
|
|
Photo by Robin Solomon
Keys to ID:
-
Blue Jay-sized,
on average 10-14 inches long; female is larger; can be similar to
small Cooper's.
-
Narrow hips and broad
chest; center of gravity higher than Cooper's
-
Thinner, pencil-like
legs than Cooper's.
-
Square, long tail;
outer tail feathers usually the longest
-
Hooded appearance from
dark feathers on crown and neck
-
Quick,
erratic wingbeats; small head barely extends past the
wings
|
 |
|
 |
|
The Cooper's "cap."
Photo by Virginia Kadow
|
|
The sharpie's gray "hood."
Photo by Marie Lehmann
|
 |
|
 |
|
Rounded Cooper's Hawk
tails
Top photo by David Lang,
bottom photo by Gerald Levitz
|
|
More squared-off sharpie
tails
Top photo by Robin Solomon,
bottom photo by Frank Moltz
|
|